Size the pool from the plan, not a percentage
Lead investors usually ask for an unissued option pool of a set size after their round, and for the increase to come out of the pre-money valuation. That means the founders and earlier investors bear the dilution, not the new money.
The best defense is a hiring plan. If you can show the specific hires you'll make before the next round and what each will receive, the pool can be sized to that plan instead of a round number.
Enter your plan and this calculator works out the pool you need, the top-up and, if you model a round, what that top-up costs today's holders.